Grammar-Quizzes › Verb Phrases › Verb Complements › Ditransitive Verbs (indirect object)
| INDIRECT OBJECT | ||
|---|---|---|
A ditransitive verb requires a direct object ("patient", person or thing affected by the action) and an indirect object ("recipient", person to whom something is given) to complete its meaning. The indirect object takes form as a noun phrase—a name Jane, a noun phrase the young woman, or an accusative pronoun him, her, them, us, me. |
||
| SUBJ + PREDICATE | INDIRECT OBJ | DIRECT OBJ |
| NP + V | NP | NP |
Angela gave |
me |
a journal. |
Angela gave |
the librarian |
a textbook. |
Angela found |
Adam |
an out-of-print book. |
Angela asked |
the librarian |
the title. |
Angela lent / *borrowed |
him |
a book. |
Angela showed |
~the kids in the class from Edison Elementary school³ |
a novel. |
| PREPOSITIONAL PHRASE "TO" | ||
|---|---|---|
Alternatively, information about "the recipient" can be expressed in a prepositional phrase¹ with to. The phrase expresses the same meaning as the indirect object; however, because a prepositional phrase functions differently from a noun phrase in a clause², it is called a verbal complement rather than an indirect object. See Terminology. |
||
| SUBJ + PREDICATE | DIRECT OBJ | COMPLEMENT |
| NP + V | NP | PP |
Angela gave |
a journal |
to me. |
Angela gave |
a textbook |
to the librarian |
Angela found |
an old book |
for Adam. |
Angela asked |
the title |
*to the librarian. |
Angela lent |
a book |
to him. |
Angela suggested |
a novel |
to the kids in the class from Edison Elementary school. |
* not used / ~borderline usage
¹ This departs from the traditional analysis, where a prepositional phrase with to me or for me is analyzed as an indirect object. Though the indirect object and the prepositional phrase express a similar meaning, they do not function (are not used) in the same way in a clause. See Noun Properties or Preposition Properties.
² A prepositional phrase with to functions differently from an indirect object. For example, an indirect object can function as the subject of a passive construction but a prepositional phrase cannot. I was given a journal by Angela. *To me was given a journal by Angela. (Huddleston 4.4.3)
³ There is a tendency for speakers to move lengthy or wordy elements to the end of a clause. When the indirect object is lengthy, it is often reworded as a prepositional phrase and placed after the direct object. This is not a rule. It is not considered less formal. See Placement Exceptions.
recipient – the person or thing that is the receiver, the endpoint of the action; He gave the letter to her.
to – has a few meanings, for example, "the goal in physical movement" He went to work; "endpoint in change of state" He went to sleep; "endpoint in duration" He works from 9 to 5. (Huddleston 7 § 6.2)
dative case – Latin grammar term
Also see Intransitive Verbs – Never Passive!
In order to understand this topic, it is important to separate "semantic role" (information expressed) from "function" (its grammatical name/term in a clause.) For example, a direct object does not always express information about the "patient" (the person/thing affected by the action.) See Give v. Thank.
Word Categories: N – Noun; V – Verb; Aux – Auxiliary; Adj – Adjective; Adv – Adverb; P –Preposition; Det –Determiner. See Word Categories.
Phrasal Categories: NP – Noun Phrase; VP – Verb Phrase; AdjP – Adjective Phrase; AdvP – Adverb Phrase; PP – Prepositional Phrase; DP – Determinative Phrase.
Clausal Categories: Cls – clause; F – finite clause; NF – nonfinite clause: Ger – gerund; Inf – infinitive; PPart – past participle.
Word Functions: Subj – subject; Pred – predicate/predicator; Comp – complement: elements required by an expression to complete its meaning (DO – direct object; IO – indirect object); Adjunct – adjunct: elements not required by an expression to complete its meaning (Subord – subordinator; Coord – coordinator); Supl – supplement: a clause or phrase added onto a clause that is not closely related to the central thought or structure of the main clause.
Also see Aarts 4.1.3.1-2 or Huddleston 4 §8.2.1 as referenced in Grammar Notes (below).
¹ an indirect object, which expresses "person affected by action", is more central to the meaning expressed by the subject and predicate of a clause. It takes form as a noun phrase, a word form which can function (occupy, be used as) the subject in a passive construction. He was given a letter.
In contrast, a prepositional phrase expresses several meanings that an indirect object cannot: timing, location, manner, possession, frequency, degree and more. It takes form as a preposition + other structures, which cannot occupy the subject position in a passive construction *To him was given a letter. (See Properties of Prepositions )
Passives: either the direct or indirect object could function as the subject of the passive sentence. (Swan 6.10)
(Aarts 4.1.3.2, 4.2) (Huddleston 4 §8.2)
award They awarded him a prize. / They awarded a prize to him. |
bring They brought him a pie. / They brought a pie to him. |
deny They denied him a place. / They denied a place to him. |
feed They fed him a pie. / They fed a pie to him. |
give They gave him a prize. / They gave a prize to him. |
hand They handed him a prize. / They handed a prize to him. |
kick They kicked him the ball. / They kicked the ball to him. |
leave¹ My father left me his house. / My father left his house to me. |
lend They lent him some money. / They lent some money to him. |
offer They offered him a job. / They offered a job to him. |
owe They owed him some money. / They owed some money to him. |
pass They passed him the ball. / They passed the ball to him. |
post She posted him a note. / She posted a note to him. |
promise They promised him a job / They promised a job to him. |
read They read him a paragraph. / They read a paragraph to him. |
roll He rolled us the ball. / He rolled the ball to us. |
sell They sold him a car. / They sold a car to him. |
send They sent him a message. / They sent a message to him. |
serve They served him a meal. / They served a meal to him. |
show They showed him a picture. / They showed a picture to him. |
sing He sand me a song. / He sang a song to me. |
take They took him his phone. / They took his phone to him. |
teach They taught him slang. / They taught slang to him. |
tell They told him a lie. / They told a lie to him. |
throw They threw him a ball. / They threw a ball to him. |
write They wrote him a message. / They wrote a message to him. |
¹ left –bequeath (give to someone at a future time after one's death)
² sing to someone – direct the message of the song to someone
Related page: Say / Tell | Said Synonyms
| INDIRECT OBJECT | |||
|---|---|---|---|
With a particular group of verbs such as buy, the beneficiary is expressed with a direct object. |
|||
| SUBJ | PRED | IO | DO |
| NP | V | NP | NP |
My friend |
bought |
me (recipient) |
a present. |
| PREPOSITIONAL PHRASE "FOR" | |||
|---|---|---|---|
Additionally, the beneficiary can be expressed with a prepositional phrase with for. This may be understood in two ways: [1] the intended recipient, [2] "in place of someone else" "in order to help someone". |
|||
| SUBJ | PRED | DO | COMP |
| NP | V | NP | PP |
My friend |
bought |
a present |
for me. |
beneficiary – one who receives the benefit or enjoyment of an action or event; He sang the song for her. (for her benefit, enjoyment, advantage)
for – has several different meanings: "in favor of" I am for a tax cut; "as a favor to" I fixed it for you; "intended recipient" The package is for you; "beneficiary" Say a prayer for me; "on behalf of" I am speaking for my elderly mother; "duration" We stayed for a week; "distance" We walked for a mile; "as a result of" It was worse for the wear; "reason or purpose" He won't answer me for some reason; "suitability" It's time for a change; "destination" We're headed for the gym; "consideration or relation to" It is surprisingly warm for wintertime; and others "favorable orientation toward" He asked for help. (Huddleston 7 § 6.2)
The prepositional phrase with for is not called an indirect object because it cannot not function in exactly the same way that a noun (noun phrase) can. See Grammar Notes.
bake He baked me a cake. / He baked a cake for me. |
build He built them a playhouse. / He built a playhouse for them. |
buy She bought me some ice cream. / She bought some ice cream for me. |
cook She cooked them dinner. / She cooked dinner for them. |
design The architect designed them a house./ He designed a house for them. |
do She did me a favor. / She did a favor for me. |
get She got me a job. / She got a job for me. |
find She found us a home. / She found a home for us. |
hire He hired us a new driver. / He hired a new driver for us. |
leave¹ The agent left us a new proposal. / The agent left a new proposal for us. |
make The made me a costume. / They made a costume for me. |
prescribe She prescribed me some medicine. / She prescribed some medicine for me |
rent He rented me a house. / He rented a house for me. |
save They save me a seat at the concert. / They saved a seat for me. |
sing The singer sang us his new song. / He sang his new song for us. |
write She wrote the President a letter.. / She wrote a letter to the President. |
¹ left – let something stay behind for someone's benefit He left some papers for us.; left – accidentally forget something He left his phone at home.
² (1) sing for someone – the listener enjoys the song (benefits); (2) the singer sings in place of another person who is unable to do so.
(Aarts 4.1.3.2, 4.2) (Huddleston 4 §8.2)
| INDIRECT OBJECT | |||
|---|---|---|---|
With some verbs such as open, the beneficiary of the action cannot be expressed as an indirect object. |
|||
| SUBJ | PRED | IO | DO |
| NP | V | NP | NP |
My friend |
opened |
*me |
a letter. |
| PREPOSITIONAL PHRASE "FOR" | |||
|---|---|---|---|
The beneficiary is expressed as a prepositional phrase with for. The clause can be understood in two ways (1) the letter was for me; (2) the action was done for me (instead of me). |
|||
| SUBJ | PRED | DO | COMPLEMENT |
| NP | V | NP | PP |
My friend |
opened |
a letter |
for me. |
| INDIRECT OBJECT |
|---|
— |
acquire Our parents acquired the property for us.. |
answer He is answering the question for me. |
borrow They borrowed a car for us to use. |
cash He cashed a check for me |
close They closed the doors for us. |
collect The boy collected the eggs for us. |
compose They composed a birthday song for her. |
(ex)change He exchanged the shoes for me. |
fabricate They fabricated a new design for the company. |
obtain He obtained permission for us to enter. |
open He opened an account for me |
perform He performed the scene for us. |
pronounce He pronounced the word for me. |
recover The police recovered the stolen painting for us.. |
retrieve The dog retrieved the newspaper for his owner. |
withdraw The man withdrew the money for his parents. |
When a clause has one object, that object is always called direct object, even when its meaning is that of receiver or beneficiary of the action. That is, an indirect object is found only in combination with a direct object.
With such verbs, the receiver (recipient) "is most directly associated with the verb" and is, therefore, called the direct object of the clause. He hit me with a stick. He blamed me for the accident. He excused me for the offense. (Huddleston 251, 281)
| GIVE | ||
|---|---|---|
Verbs such as give or tell require a direct object [DO] and optionally include an indirect object [IO]. The "recipient" information of the indirect object can be moved after the direct object and worded as a prepositional phrase with for or to, with no difference in meaning. |
||
| SUBJ + PRED | INDIRECT OBJ. | DIRECT OBJ. |
| NP + V | NP | PP [PREP + NP] |
You gave You bought |
me me |
a gift. a gift. |
| S – V | DIRECT OBJ. | VERBAL COMPLEMENT |
| NP + V | NP | PP [PREP + NP] |
You gave You bought |
a gift a gift |
to me. (receiver) for me. (beneficiary) |
| THANK | ||
|---|---|---|
Thank does NOT require a direct object ("patient" – the thing affected by action). Instead it requires an indirect object ("recipient" – the person that is the receiver or endpoint of the action). Information about the "patient" (thing affected by the action) may optionally be included in a prepositional phrase (which is called a verbal complement rather than the direct object.) |
||
| SUBJ + PRED | DIRECT OBJ¹ | DIRECT OBJ. |
| NP + V | NP | — |
(I) Thank |
you¹. ("sole object") |
— |
| SUBJ + PRED | DIRECT OBJ.¹ | VERBAL COMPLEMENT |
| NP + V | NP | PP [PREP + NP] |
(I) Thank He praised |
you¹ me |
for the gift. (reason) for my progress. (reason) |
¹Sole Object– note that you is labeled as the direct object. Typically the receiver or beneficiary of the action is the indirect object. However, when the indirect object occurs alone without a direct object, it becomes the direct object. In other words, an object is only labeled an indirect object if there is already a direct object. (Huddleston 251, 281)
Verbs like give include buy, bring, hand, lend, read, show, take, offer, pass, write (See examples in sections above.)
Verbs like thank include praise, acknowledge, admire, applaud, criticize, rebuke, reprimand, scold, blame, condemn, censure.
| THANK | ||
|---|---|---|
Thank requires a "recipient" (receiver of the action) to complete it and stand on its own as a clause. Information about "the thing affected by the action" (the gift) can optionally be included in a prepositional phrase. When there is only one object, it is called the direct object. That is, the term indirect object is only used if there is already a direct object. |
||
| SUBJ + PRED | DIRECT OBJ.¹ | VERBAL COMPLEMENT |
| NP + V | NP | PP [PREP + NP] |
(I) Thank |
you¹ ("sole object") |
for the gift.(reason) |
| LISTEN | ||
|---|---|---|
Listen requires an adjunct prepositional phrase with information about the "recipient" (person/thing that is the endpoint of the action). The meaning of this verb has no need for a direct object but more information can be included with additional prepositional phrases. Listen to me about this situation. See Verb+Prep List for other verbs like this. |
||
| SUBJ + PRED | (NONE) | ADJUNCT PREP PHRASE |
| NP + V | NP | PP [PREP + NP] |
(You) Listen We spoke He talks He lies He apologized |
— |
to me. (goal/endpoint) to them. (goal/endpoint) to them. (goal/endpoint) to them. (goal/endpoint) to them. (goal/endpoint) |
Look Laugh |
— |
at them. (location) at them. (location) |
I agree He differs |
— |
with them. (accompaniment) from me. (source location) |
Listen is included among a large number of verbs that "specify" a particular preposition, which means the verb "selects" (is typically followed by) one particular preposition which completes its meaning. For a list of verb + prep. combinations, see Verb + Prep List.
Also see Thank you for -ing. for similar verbs.
| IT / THEM |
|---|
When the direct object is a personal pronoun like it or them, the indirect object is restated as a prepositional phrase at the end of the clause. |
Will you please give me it? ⇒ Will you please give it to me. |
I am showing my family them. ⇒ I am showing them to my family.
|
| LENGTHY OBJECTS |
|---|
Speakers often prefer to state the recipient as an indirect object rather than a prepositional phrase If the direct object is lengthy (if the verb permits) , |
Please give that purple and pink poster that you have on the wall to me. ⇒ Please give me that purple and pink poster that you have on the wall. |
I will sell the television with the forty-inch screen and surround sound to him. → I will sell him the television with the forty-inch screen and surround sound. |
| ERROR |
|---|
* You bought for me a sandwich.
|
* Thank you the sandwich.
|
~ He gave me it. |
| SOLUTION |
|---|
You bought a sandwich for me. (Place the prepositional phrase at the end of the clause.) |
Thank you for the sandwich. (If you include the item (noun), place it in a preposition phrase with for.) |
He gave it to me. Avoid using two short pronouns. He gave me the letter. Expand one of the pronouns. |
* Incorrect / ~borderline usage
| TRADITIONAL GRAMMAR |
|---|
In traditional grammar, to me and for me are referred to as indirect objects. (Swan "Verbs with two objects" 610) |
You bought me a gift. You bought for me a gift. / You bought a gift for me.
See Preposition Grammar Notes for other diagrams |
| LINGUISTIC DESCRIPTION |
|---|
In linguistic description, a monotransitive verb takes a noun phrase (NP) as its complement. A ditransitive verb takes a direct object and an indirect object as its complements. The phrases to me and for me are categorized as prepositional phrases rather than indirect objects. The meaning is the same. (Huddleston "Direct and Indirect Objects" 244-6, "Ditransitive Clauses" 248, Ditransitive/monotransitive contrasts" 308-9) |
Recipient themes involve: (Huddleston 4 §8.2.1)
to — a recipient or locational goal: She offered the book to the library. (recipient); She took her son to the library. (locative)
Beneficiary themes involve: (Huddleston 4 §8.2.1)
for – a beneficiary, one who receives the benefit or enjoyment of an action or event; He sang the song for her. (for her benefit, enjoyment, advantage) Also see Aarts 4.1.3.1-2. |
Word Categories: N – Noun; V – Verb; Aux – Auxiliary; Adj – Adjective; Adv – Adverb; P –Preposition; Det –Determiner.
Phrasal Categories: NP – Noun Phrase; VP – Verb Phrase; AdjP – Adjective Phrase; AdvP – Adverb Phrase; PP – Prepositional Phrase; DP – Determinative Phrase.
Clausal Categories: Cls – clause; F – finite clause; NF – nonfinite clause (Ger – gerund; Inf – infinitive; PPart – past participle).
Word Functions: Subj – subject; Pred – predicate/predicator; Comp – complement: an element or elements required by a word or structure to complete its meaning in the clause (e.g., DO – direct object; IO – indirect object; PP - prep. phrase); Adjunct – adjunct: elements not required by an expression to complete its meaning (Subord – subordinator; Coord – coordinator); Supl – supplement: a clause or phrase added onto a clause that is not closely related to the central thought or structure of the main clause.
