skip navigation
 

TitanicPast Unreal Situations 2

Analyzing an accident

 

 

What Caused the Titanic to Sink?

 

CONDITIONS LEADING TO THE ACCIDENT HYPOTHETICAL CAUSE - EFFECT STATEMENTS

When we reflect on a past accident, we analyze the conditions to understand what we needed to do to avoid the accident.  Read the following conditions and determine what errors were made.

Hypothetical past statements are not factual (untrue). The statement in the if-clause did not occur. These conditionals state what we could have done to avoid  or change the course of a tragedy.

Speed - The Titanic was trying to beat a trans-Atlantic time crossing record.

If the Captain had cruised at a lower speed and postponed setting a 'crossing' record, the watchmen might have spotted the iceberg in time.

Lifeboats - The Titanic had lifeboats and preservers for less than half of the people on board

If the White Star Line had included more life boats in the design of the Titanic, all the people would have survived.

 

 

 

Conditional Tense Structure

The past conditional is used to speculate about past events: plans and actions that did not occur.  Typically, would have, could have, should have are used, and occasionally, might have and may have.
 

HAD + PAST PARTICIPLE MODAL + HAVE + PARTICIPLE

In the if-clause, state the situation or condition that unfortunately did not occur.

In the other clause, indicate the hypothetical action resolving the problem.  Usually, the verb takes the form of would have, could have or should have + participle.

If Jack had seen the iceberg, 
(the hero in the Titanic movie)

he would have told the captain.

If Rose had known  it,
(the main character in the Titanic movie)

she could have left him earlier.

If Molly had talked any longer,
(a character in the movie)

she would have put everyone to sleep.

If Cal had been a better man, 
(the villain in the movie)

he might have acted in a kinder manner.

 

 

If-Clause Order
COMMA NO COMMA

Use a comma to separate the two clauses when the if-clause comes first.

Use no comma when the if-clause comes second.

If we had known the movie was long, we would have gotten some popcorn.

We would have gotten some popcorn if we had known the movie was long.

If we had gotten here earlier, we could have found better seats.

We could have found better seats if we had gotten here earlier.

 

 

 

 

Practice

Analysis: looking at the whole situation

 

 

 

When we analyze a catastrophe such as the sinking of the Titantic, we try to find the factors, the human errors, which lead to the disaster.

  • speed
  • insufficient number of lifeboats
  • binoculars
  • ship design
  • angle of impact
  • emergency response time of Titanic crew
  • radio-operator on the nearby ship California, had his radio off.
  • not enough / insufficient lifeboats
  • insufficiently filled lifeboats
  • gates locking 'steerage passengers' below deck
  • calling Titanic "unsinkable"

 

  1. Select the word from each menu that best completes the sentence. 
  2. Compare your response to the answer by clicking the "check" button to the right. 
# SELECT THE CORRECT VERB FORMS CHECK ANSWER
1.

 

2.

 

3.  

 

4.  

 

5.  

 

6  

 

7.  

 

8.  

 

9.  

 

10.  (tempt=provoke; brought on the "evil eye")

 

   

 

 

 

 

 

Text View of Answers

  1. If the White Star Line had included more life boats, all the people would have survived.
  2. If the watch crew had located some binoculars before leaving England, they would have seen the iceberg earlier.
  3. If the ship designers had included more safety compartments to keep the ship afloat, the ship might have stayed afloat until the Carpathia arrived.
  4. If the Captain had steered directly into the iceberg, the ship would have had less damage.
  5. Help might have come more quickly if the crew had reacted more quickly,
  6. The ship near by, California would have received the emergency call if the radio-operator had had his radio turned on.
  7. If the White Star Line had supplied enough life jackets for everyone, all the bodies would have been found.
  8. More people would have survived if the crew had filled the lifeboats completely,
  9. Third-class passengers in compartments below deck might have had a chance if the crew had not locked them in.
  10. If The White Star Shipping Line hadn't called the Titanic "unsinkable", they wouldn't have tempted fate.